Why are you asking me what 1911 to get? I am New Jovian Thunderbolt. Emphasis on New. What do I know?
It's been goin
around.
I can only pass on received knowledge. You shoulda asked Tam a while back. Though I don't think she'd have taken the bait. Because what if things change? People today using her 'list' from 2012 or 2008 (just as a fer instance) might be buying a pistol in a totally different environment.
I have a bit more under my belt now. A coupla armorers class. A few thousand rounds. But you want to ask the pistol smith that knows what he or she is doing and has tens of thousands of rounds under his belt.
I can pass along what the gunsmith said, and what my current mindset is.
Springfields are halfway decent. Not perfect, by any means.
Get a Howa or an RIA. Then soup up from there. With a few armors classes.
I avoid the high dollar high option semi-custom 1911s now. Why? I can add my own after market stuff now, and I've seen too many high end guns with more problems than my GI Springfield. I avoid Series 80 guns because fewer fiddly bits.
One thing I do sorta regret with the GI type gun? The sights aren't dovetailed in front, and not dovetailed enough in back. And I don't have the mill or ability to correct that.
And before you Glock/Sig/M&P people say "just get one like mine, and it works right out of the box." Well, all the 1911s I've seen and held and shot and what not have 'worked well right out of the box.' In that they worked as well as your gun does. And I've seen the stuff that can go wrong inside YOUR gun, now, too. It comes from the factory with flaws, too. One thing is those flaws can be easy to fix and stay on top of. (the safety plunger on the Glock... yeah you Glock people should take a good Glock armorer class...)
So... what 1911 to get... Well, I can tell you what I'd get if I was shopping for a 1911:
A Howa
An RIA
A lower end Springfield (but not, I'd intend to do a lot of work to any of these three)
I'd look at STI.
S&W and Remington I might keep in the back of my mind.
But I know even MORE stuff to look at before plunking down the credit card. If I was really lucky I'd find a store that let me field strip a pistol.