Monday, January 10, 2011

Biggest Mistake

It is said the biggest mistake in politics is when a politician is caught actually telling the truth.

My Buddy the Gun Enthusiast ran into this flavor of truth telling with a 1911 gunsmith.  He went on a little tirade about the flaws of the 1911 and how it keeps him deep into car payment and bacon money:
"1911s are the perfect storm. They are expensive and need a lot of gun smithing to sort out their bugs." He continued, "The design is a hundred years old, we learned a lot in that hundred years. The mag design alone is awful. Even Jeff Cooper would bitch about their capacity and reliability now. What the F&%k, it's been a hundred years.  People still love em though. This little guy you have will jam at least once every hundred rounds, I'd bet money."

Wow.  Shocking in his forthright alacrity.

Now admittedly, I haven't shot a variety of 1911s, but I have never had a jam that was the gun's fault but maybe once for 1000 rounds.  And I've used those truncated wad cutterish rounds (50, no issue) and maybe 150 hollow points (all hydra-shoks), the rest FMJ.  My initial jams were from my own poor grip, where the first finger of my support hand (right) was pushing out the little button of the slide stop on the right hand side of the gun.  Most of my experience is with my mid range Springfield and the only gunsmithing I've put it through is the of the kitchen table variety where I swapped our various parts to please my own feature preferences as I developed them: guide rod, grips, grip safety, mainspring housing.

Now MBtGE's 1911 that he's been playing with is a low price point Rock Island job.  I've shot a bunch out of it myself.  I was surprised a $300 gun didn't seem much different than mine at over twice the price, in reliable function, at least.  But MBtGE reports some stoppages, clearly.  I've seen it jam but with other people and I think their problem was limp wristing.  Nothing that can't be corrected by gripping 20% tighter.

I have had a mechanical failure with mine.  The pin that holds the mainspring housing in place snapped at the range. But that shouldn't count against it, except maybe in the MIM pin department.  If the pins are MIM...

My on again off again love affair with the 1911 is only from being slightly intimidated carrying in Condition 1 and that it pokes me a bit with the extended thumb safety and that I can't seem to shoot it as well as other single action items.  All these are problems with me, and not the gun.

So I don't understand the haranguing the pistol gets outside of mere 'other gun, not mine' fanboy ribbing.  Buy a decent modern defensive 1911, don't truly monkey with it by breaking out the peening hammer or dremel stones, don't get a bullseye pistol with slide and bushing tighter than a frog's butt, and clean and lubricate after every other range trip and I don't see why they won't run great right out of the box, so to speak.  Gunnutmegger even has personal data from a larger selection of examples recorded so it's not like he making up observed issues.  Maybe I need 20,000 rounds under my belt to get disillusioned, but Tam has that in spades and it doesn't appear to causing her to rethink her thought processes and gun choice.  In fact, she's been down this road so many times that when someone posits that her 1911s are somehow inappropriate she shrugs and keeps on carrying her 10+ year old Springfield on her hip, unswayed.

Maybe I am getting more jams and not noticing, just quickly correcting the issue and driving on.  But I can't be that instinctive that I just operate it well.  I'm still too n00b for that kind of competence, methinks.  About the only thing I can remember is when the 1911 is dry sometime it doesn't fully feed and a light tap of the rail puts the round in battery.  That's happened to me.  But had I cleaned the thing recently it never does.  And I can say with confidence I have never had a stovepipe or a double feed or a failure to eject.  The only gun I have that has done that was a NASTY stovepipe in my Sig that cut the brass half way down by the frame.  Once.

So, back to the subject of MBtGE 1911 gunsmith...  Why so glum about the model?  And the projecting onto Cooper about the 'flaw' of low mag capacity?  I dunno about that.  The spare magazine you carry isn't for shooting the 8th 9th and 10th determined bad guy in a gun fight.

(note: I link to Tam a lot because she has often already said something I concur with and said it much better that I ever could.  if I could live a parallel lives I'd want to model 20 years of one life toward traveling a similar path, reading and researching to the same extent, working with a quality gun purveyor, taking the same classes, to the same concentration she has)

Do I think the 1911 design is perfect?  No, not perfect.  But it's damn good, no?  Since it's inception other designs have offered up different feature tradeoffs, been made to be easier to master, and been sent up with an eye toward easier and cheaper manufacture, been formulated to need less routing maintenance and fettling to shoot right out of the box or right out of the nightstand, but nothing in 100 years can be said to be objectively BETTER at sending little lead and copper pills downrange.  There is certainly a place of modern design

And a gunsmith won't get rich specializing in Glocks.  That gunsmith quoted is lucky in that LOTS of people the past 100 years have done things to their 1911 to actually NEED his corrective services, yes.  And there 100 years of customization thoughts that folks may want his services for, too.  If people were as enthused and faddish about modifying their Glocks as they are with 1911s he might get a decent revenue stream there, too.  "But people don't NEED to modify a Glock," you may argue.  'Need' has nothing to do with it.  You don't need to modify your 1911, either.  People want to, so, thus they want to give money to 1911 smiths.  And you CAN modify a 1911.  Much harder to want to modify a Glock, sorta like modifying a 2010 BMW.  You can't even see the engine on those when you pop the hood.  Tinkering with your 1971 charger or 1938 Ford is much more accessible.  Same with 1911 v. Glock. 

So maybe that gunsmith shouldn't be denigrating how the gun pays the rent for him, it's the 1911 PEOPLE that bring him the business.  The model doesn't need the tinkering, but the owners want the tinkering or want to fix past tinkering that went all wrong or want to fix the wear and tear done to favorite heater over its long life.  (and Gunnutmegger admits as much long before it occurred to me here, "but I think missing one point in the original post. It’s the slavish adoration that’s the problem, not the gun itself")

[Update: I should also add that I haven't shot more than 50 rounds out of my Springfield with the factory magazine.  The rest have been all Chip McCormick.  That might have something to do with relative trouble free experiences.]

Sunday, January 9, 2011

Unintentional Heroes


I figure a little pick me up is appropo.  Zero gun content.  Some "In your FACE, Nazis" content.  Good job Fresno.  Click to embiggen.

Pricey

I got word somewhere via the blogs that the Civilian Marksmanship Program was selling a parts kit for M14s.  Everything but the receiver, bolt, and barrel.  Perfect!  Spares, and actual US Gummint Issue, for my M1A.  Then I got to their eStore and...  $600!  Well.  That's more money than I'd thought they'd be.

I actually have a few spare parts, picked up from Fulton Armory when I got the rifle itself from them.  A bag of springs and pins sights parts.  I try to do that on primary weapons.  Get the spare parts before I need them in case I break something 20 years from now and the parts are too dear to purchase for love or money then.  I keep them in my gunsmithing box.  The parts are kept in a ziplock storage bag that is well marked for each model of boomstick.  I can grab a bag of tiny 1911 springs and pins or a bad of Garand springs and pins, etc. 

The only thing I really lack is a spare bolt for the M1A, but those are pretty hard to find themselves.  I may have to pass on the $600 in used parts that don't even include a bolt, USGI cachet or no.

Saturday, January 8, 2011

zeds

click to embiggen

Shots Fired

Oh dear.  And Congresswoman Giffords (D-AZ) is among the 12 victims.

If THIS is the shooters YouTube page, he may be simply bat-shite CUHrazy.

There are rants there about each of us forming a new currency, weird date numerology, mind control paranoia, hefty-bag plastic MC Hammer pants.  Flag burning.  Yeah.  Well, crap.

I imagine YouTube will pull that video series soon enough.

High School friend on Twitter describe him as a pothead, "political radical " and "he was left wing, quite liberal. & oddly obsessed with the 2012 prophecy" back in 2007.  His MySPace page listed reading material as Mein Kampf AND the Communist Manifesto, as well as Ayn Rand and Aldus Huxley.  His youtube stuff (if it is him) shows him as goldbug type with weird Constitutional theories, and the meaner media sources are trying to paint him as a 'Teabagger,' stressing military connections, and blaming Palin for her targeting of Gifford, who was apparently pro-Obamacare AND hardline on immigration, for electoral defeat.  No, painting political actions onto the actions of a clearly insane individual is not appropriate.  Crazy did this, not politics.  It's not the gun, it's not the Right, it's not the Left, it's the man.

Related, THIS is the best advice from Twitter, from Elizabeth Scalia.

8:15

in...




Advice about gun control from a Red Sox Fan. And his father.


But watch the whole series of films.  This is the end of Pt 2.  The rest of it is about baseball.


Up until 2004, MY team had won a World Series sooner than the Sox had.  The original Washington Senators.  One day, there will return home to DC and we'll have a ball team again.

Friday, January 7, 2011

Help Me Internet Kenobi

You're my only hope...

So I stopped at a gunstore and saw one of these:


You all know I talking about a Combat Commander...

What I need YOU to do is talk me down off the ledge and not go back and buy it after work...

Or, conversely, goad me into getting it.

All in comments, but mind you, I need a why.  Why get it or why wait.

Reasons to:
  1. It's a Colt.  While that cache doesn't hold me as the be all end all, it does have some influence on me.  I'm not impervious.  It's the company with the same letterhead that made the original 1911 100 years ago, after all.  It'd be my one real purchase of 2011. (ha!)
  2. It's THERE.  I've been looking on and off for a while and this is the first one I've seen where I could plop down the money and get it.
  3. It has most all the features I want.  And it really doesn't need any monkeying with, really, to make me happy with what it doesn't have. (night sights, that bump in the grip safety...)  I might swap out the grips and be done.  If I got it.
Reasons not:
  1. It's got MIM parts in it.  Sure my Springfield Loaded does too, I'm sure.  That didn't stop me then.  And MIM isn't ALL bad.  Probably give me a lifetime of trouble free service.  I can slowly swap out the internals at the gunsmith over time to forging, except the frame.
  2. It's pricey, but that hasn't stopped me, before, you all know.
  3. I'd be better off, maybe, getting the XD40 at half the price of this.  I bet I'd shoot the XD better. 
  4. Other reasons I'm counting on YOU to tell me to wait and get some other Combat Commander at some future date. 
  5. I don't want the enthusiasm of the find make me purchase in haste.

I may have to go look at it, and handle it, regardless.  And if it has a sold sticker on it already, well...  That's Cthore, God of Thunderboomers, telling me it wasn't to be at this time and I'll accept that philosophically.

If I did get it, that would end my 1911 desires for years and years.  I'd have my spare.  No more .45 pistols would come to grace my safe or need to.


You have til 2PM EST to respond...

Thursday, January 6, 2011

Hoplophobe Paw

I've made complaints in the past that my father is a hoplophobe.  That's not fair to him.  He is not scared, per se.  He is one of those that didn't necessarily ever want a gun in the house.  Even one that was his.  And he had more than one.  Well hidden in a closet. 

We lived in the suburbs.  My grandfather lived in the country.  My dad didn't think twice about shooting a bb gun there in the middle of the Ek-Veldt.  Or shooting a 20 gauge for fun.  Or had problems with the notion of shooting that same 20 gauge at rabbits in the garden.  So he is more nuanced than a 'mere hoplophobe.'

He still regrets not buying that Colt Woodsman or holding onto that model 39A type in New Mexico, 1959.  Both .22s that he liked.  He used the lever action 39A to hunt jack rabbits.  Pests near his Air Force base that the father/property-owner of a buddy wanted rid of.

So he is not a true hoplophobe.  He'd shoot a pest animal if the situation called for it.  Probably a threatening human if the threat was dire and he was armed and there was no alternative.  But isn't that just like the rest of us?  We gunnies would only shoot a human if the threat was dire and we were armed and there was no alternative.

Wednesday, January 5, 2011

Ah, Good

I did not know this. 

The Defense Authorization Bill for fiscal year 2011.  It prevents the military from forcing off-base residing military personnel from registering their firearms with on-base authorities.

Some base commanders got the idea that if they required registration somehow that would prevent a repeat of what happened with that Nidal guy shooting folks at Ft Hood.  I have no idea how that thought process occurred to them and they thought it would be effective, except as an extension of their instinctive reaction to take charge and command and appear to do something after a catastrophic failure.  High ranking .mil folks are human I guess.

Tuesday, January 4, 2011

Last Year's

10 Most Underreported News Stories

Revolver Wistful

Sometimes I think life would be easier if John Moses Browning (pbuh)* hadn't invented the auto-pistol.  It'd be less for me to think about.  I'd own 3 or 4 total of various sizes, one .22 and the others .38/.357 and I='d never have to worry about safety catches and manual of arms and malf drills with a tappa and a racka and a banga. 

I mean, what DO we really get with those auto chuckers?  A few more rounds to shoot?  Fast reloads?  If you need to shoot more than 5 bring a spare revolver.  Or bring friends.

I say 4 revolvers are needed and I only own 3.  Where is my hole?  Medium length barrel.  I have a 6 inch barrel for the house, a snubbie for the pocket, but I am missing something in a Model 13 or 65 size for a belt holster and CCW that way.  Perfection.  Ease of ammo storage.  A good carbine offering.  No one complains the .357 is not enough cartridge for the job.  I wouldn't be casting about with thoughts about the semi-auto if the caliber was inadequate (i have no idea where i was going with that last sentence).  Revolver shooting is America's martial art, with none of that kicking or chopping or 'heeeeeYAH!' shouting.

Yeah, life as a gunnie would be simpler.  But if wishes were horse we'd all be eating steak.

If the whole semi-auto fad had proven to be a flash in the pan that petered out in 1912 or so, Colt would still be making the Python.  You'd be able to get .41 and .44 special ammo at WalMart.  And we'd argue over caliber, still.  I'd still be fine with the .357.

*(and yes, I was being facetious about JMB inventing the semi-auto form.  He just perfected it.  Probably for all time.)

Monday, January 3, 2011

Dreams of Fodder

I had a few great gun related dreams.  Subject matter interesting enough to make blog posts about.  I was quite pleased. 

I can't for the life of me remember them now...

A Scout is Back

I'd get this!  I'd get TWO!!!.  I wonder if it's in a lefty model...  Finally a decent but not too expensive bolt action rifle I can use and love.  I've been intrigued enough with the Scout concept since I learned of its existence, via Jeff Cooper.

Wait.  No lefty listed.  Phooey.  Ruger is still only into me for the .22.   And I doubt that will change.

Review for those new to the concept...  Cooper pushed to design a rifle that would be of almost universal utility.  He had 'big' conferences of riflemen to get the details down, but I think his influence was the most telling.  He wanted something that was a short stroke major caliber bolt action gun able to take any game in North America.  The ammo had to be nearly universally available in North America or elsewhere, which is why .308/7.62x51 was selected.  It had to be light, short, handy, and the long eye-relief scope was necessary for better vision, but not geared toward 800 yard shots.  And it would have iron sights for backup.  It had to be magazine fed.  He wanted a Ching Sling to be used with it.  When not hunting it could be used by a smallish cadre of competent riflemen to keep nearly any army or armed band at bay, as though he lived in South Africa during the Boer wars. 

So this was the perfect rifle for him, on any application he wanted it for in this country.  If he was going to Africa on safari he'd take it for the smaller game and use something in the .4xx for bigger critters.  In an emergency on his Arizona ranch when the narco-gangs or rogue ATF agents he crazily thought would come for him (heh, less outlandish now than in 1995 for those narco-gangs...) he'd use his 1911 to fight his way to where the Scout rifle was, and then run out the back door with it to take to the hills.

Steyr actually MADE this Scout rifle for him and he loved it.  It was commercially available but a bit pricey and never took off as well as he'd thought it should.  Cooper did also lament that the Steyr never came in a left hand model for the 15% of us that need it.  A big strike against it was the north of $2500 price tag, last I checked.  (I could be wrong.  I also thought they no longer produced it.)  This Ruger is south of a grand, msrp, so, yay.  And it looks like Ruger tried to stick to the specs rather than just offer a complet kluge of a bolty that happens to have scope mount forward of the receiver for a scout scope.

The influence on me?  Well it made me aware of the scout scope.  It's essentially a pistol scopt on a rifle.  And I love how it works.  Loved it so much I mounted one on a Garand (though I made no permanent changes to that rifle so I can convert it back with no one the wiser).  My thought was I could use the Garand for hunting at that point, but concerns about proper hunting ammo in a Navy Garand makes me hesitate to take it afield.

If you ever get a chance to try a rifle with a scout scope on it, do so.  Heck, Breda liked mine when she got to try it.  I don't know if she'd want her own because I'd bet Breda prefers playing with stuff that can better reach out to 800 yards.  I know Burruss and Leupold make a scout scope. 

But I am sold on the scout idea, pretty much.  Certainly for the bolt action hunting application.  Once some maker comes out with a lefty.

I have no bolt action rifle and have always considered that a hole in my collection.  Oh sure, I have a Springfield '03 and a .22, but both are righties and I don't want to much up the .30-06 by tapping a scope to it.  THAT would be an irreversible alteration and offends my historical artifiact sensibilities.

Sunday, January 2, 2011

Miniature Gunsmiths

No, not little people that happen to make guns...  
 
I stumbled across this Craftsmanship Museum online and immediately thought of RobertaX.  I sent her a link to the main site in her comments.  But then figured it was definitely blog worth because of the tiny-guns gunsmithing section.  Neat!

I figured I'd share.

Where I Got It

" The possession of a good rifle and the skill to use it well, truly makes a man the monarch of all he surveys. It realizes the ancient dream of the Jovian Thunderbolt, and as such is the embodiment of personal power."

-Jeff Cooper, The Art of the Rifle

Stuff I Miss

Stuff goes away...

And that was just this past year.

I miss a lot of local flavor to the DC area that just aren't here anymore.

Izzie Cohen's Big G Giant Food and Drug.

Hechts.  Now Macy's.  My goto department store.  And my mom's.

Woodworth and Lothrop.  Woodies.  Some turned into a Lord and Taylor.  It was the PRIMO department store you went to to out class Hecht's because you got a big bonus for your work down at Chesapeake & Potomac Telephone.  A part of Ma Bell.

Peoples Drug.  Despite the commie sounding name, it was much nicer than the replacement:  CVS.  What kind of name is that?  Sounds like a plumbing pipe type or a valve that a part of my air fuel mixture near my carbeurator.

Folks slightly older than me was whistful for Little Tavern and Hot Shoppes.

I was a Roy Roger's man.  Their roast beef was so good many an Arby's manager committed suicide upon sampling it.  Before that, Pappy Parker (which became Roy's), and Gino's (bought out by KFC), and for pizza: Shakey's

Saturday, January 1, 2011

More Metrocons

All my haranging of National Review being citified conservatives that are squishy on our right to have and use firearms is coming back to bite me.   Which is a good thing.  They keep sending up pro-gun pieces of late.  Here is the latest.

Sure it's the same 2 or 3 contributors, but that's better than nothing.

In this latest piece Kevin Williamson goes on about the ATF nominee Travers.  It's all review for gunnies, so nothing new, but it does get the word out to wider audiences.

Friday, December 31, 2010

Boberg

So I've been reading about the Boberg XR9S on Oleg's site and I couldn't quite put my finger on it. 

Yes yes, the magazines are loaded weird for the very compact pistol's novel operating system.  But it's something else...




Ah-HA!  It's a Noisy Cricket!


The trigger guard on the pistol put me in a mind for the prop.

I kinda like it.  The Boberg 9mm.  Well, I like the Men In Black movie rey-gun, too.

Thursday, December 30, 2010

Woot again

SAF case in MD not dismissed.  Small victory.  Case for shall-issue, here, marches on.

Had the State succeeded in getting it dismissed we'd have been back at square one or further back.  5+ years from legal relief.

Speaking of Survival

Stuff like THIS scares the heck out of me. Almost as bad as Zombies

Significant Coronal Mass Ejection or a Nork EMP in the troposphere or what have you.  All BAD-bad.  And blogging would discontinue for some time. 

If it happened today some of you readers would die of exposure this winter.  Others would starve by summer.  Those like me that work with computers for a living won't be anymore.  And we'll run the risk of heart attacks from the increase physical activity when we turn to stoop labor to try to get by.  Frank might be able to plant plenty of crop because farms would get high priority on fuel and seed this Spring, but by the fall will fuel still be there to get his harvesters going?  And if it is will the fuel be there to get the corn and soybeans to me to eat all the way out here on the East Coast?  And does anyone have a recipe for soybeans?  I have no idea how to prepare them for eating.