Nominally, VerBruggan is on our side, but there is a metrocon line he doesn't want to cross with regards to the Tennessee woman that peaceably carried in Manhattan. He seems to be of a mind that while it is a civil right, this 2nd Amendment thingy, just not in certain states. Perhaps it's not in places he pictures himself being? I dunno. He is fine with punishing this woman who failed to remember than NYC is not in America, just not TOO severely. SHE BROKE THE LAW, after all. Broke the law and... harmed... uh... no one and nothing.
His commenters take him to task on his slip up, and do a pretty good job of it. Except for the confusing one about this guy who had a friend that 'was a gun collector, attending a show in NYC'. That detail befuddled more than just me.
Update on Peruta Case - From the organizers of the NRA Civil Rights Defense Fund National Firearms Law Seminar: The deadline has passed for a judge to ask for en banc sua sponte. ...
2 hours ago